Homosexuality and medical science
The relationship between homosexuality and medical science has a long and controversial history, covering many countries and stretching across a wide spectrum of specialities, from psychology to epistemology to genetics. This article seeks to provide a brief summary of this history and a deal with some of the issues regarding homosexuality and medical science.
Table of contents |
History
The real history of homosexuality and medical science begins with the European sexologist movement which eventually spawned modern psychology. For a detailed discussion of this please see the article 'Homosexuality and psychology'.
World War II
The period from the start of the twentieth century and World War II saw a period of sexual liberation, particularly for lesbians and gay men. However, this was all to change with the rise of Fascism in Europe, particularly in Germany. The Nazi Party made use of medical science for the physical profiling to classify various races and 'criminal types', in particular homosexuality on the basis of sodomy laws. Nazi Germany, a fascist state, demanded conformity with the majority, and unfortunately for the gay community being a minority, suffered many human rights violations during this time period. Gay men were treated worse in comparison to lesbians. The exact count of how many gay men were murdered during the Holocaust is not known due to poor record keeping. (See Holocaust)
This was predominantly motivated by the fear and old prejudices that homosexuality could spread and weaken the Aryan male, and lower reproduction of the "Master Race". For more information see the article History of Gays during the Holocaust.
For many outside of the Axis territories, WWII itself was a sexually liberating experience, particularly for gay men and lesbians. The aftermath, however, brought renewed conservatism and emphasis on traditionalism. Lesbians and gay men were frequently forcibly subjected to tortures such as chemical castration, sexual reassignment surgery and electroconvulsive therapy.
AIDS crisis
When the AIDS virus first appeared in the 1980s, baffled epidemiologists sometimes described the collective symptoms they were seeing as the 'gay disease' or 'gay cancer' because it appeared to be largely restricted to gay men. The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention named the syndrome Gay Related Immune Deficiency (GRID), a name which was later replaced with Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) when it was discovered that the infected population also included heterosexuals.
AIDS was a turning point for the gay community. Despite the fact that AIDS had not yet reached pandemic proportions and more people were dying each year from Hepatitis A and B, broad media coverage was given to the AIDS epidemic in relation to the gay community. Many in the social conservative lobby saw this as evidence that what they called the "gay lifestyle" was inherently dangerous. Conversely, the gay community, beleaguered by the growing health problem as well as attacks from the press and politicians, were united by the threat. They quickly began to fight back through activism and education. Many new gay rights and gay health groups formed, such as Gay Men's Health Crisis (GMHC), and outreached to the media, politicians, and celebrities.
ACT UP, the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power, whose famous slogans include, "Silence Equals Death," organized and inventively protested on many AIDS issues including treatment, research funding, drug access, and discrimination in an effort to draw attention to the health issue.
The AIDS crisis also helped to organize the gay community. In many ways, it helped jump-start and unify the Gay Rights Movement in the aftermath of the disappointing sexual liberation movement and set the scene for the gay liberation movement during and after the 1990s.
Issues
Methods Of Reproduction Used By Same-Sex Couples
In recent years medical breakthroughs have opened a wide array of choices available to same-sex couples to have biological children.
The Main Procedures Used Are:
Gay men in long term relationships are now increasingly opting to raise families. Many methods have been devised to allow them to have biological children. Some couples elect to have a close relative (sometimes a sister), good friend, or contract an individual to either obtain an egg for a surrogate or give birth through in vitro fertilization. In the cases of a good friend or a contracted entity the child is only biologically related to one partner. However in the cases of a blood relative such as a sister of one partner who donates an egg that is fertilized with the other partner's sperm and placed into a surrogate the child is biologically related to both partners.
Lesbian couples can also produce biological children through similar manners. Some elect to have one partner donate an egg which is fertilized with a blood relative of the other partner, sometimes a brother. The egg is then placed into the partner who did not donate the egg. In essence one partner gives birth to her partner's and sometimes brother's biological child. This is not to be confused with incest since the child is not a biological offspring of a brother and sister, rather it is a biological offspring of the brother and the sister's partner. The sister only acts as a vehicle of the birth.
These procedures can be costly. And many same-sex couples choose adoption instead. However adoption does not produce a child that is biologically related in any manner.
Gay rights and medicine
Many object to the labeling of any medical condition as being gay specific because of its implicit assumptions. Medical conditions such as diseases can strike anyone regardless of their sexual orientation though certain behaviors can increase the chances of acquiring. And the "gay lifestyle" does not exist as the diversity of the gay community. Not all lesbian and gay men live their lives the same way; the belief that they do is called stereotyping. Other major intersections of gay rights with medicine include hospital visitation issues, end-of-life decision making and access/barriers to care caused by denial of civil marriages to same-sex couples. (See same-sex marriage)
Genetics
The advent of modern genetic science has seen revived interest in the argument of nature versus nurture as a cause of sexual orientation as well as advances in the treatment of AIDS and other diseases. The precise ramifications of this and modern biotechnology are not yet apparent.
However some scientific studies have pointed to findings that gay mens' brain anatomy is similar to heterosexual women and different from their heterosexual male counterparts. Other findings include that fingerprints of gay men match closely with those of heterosexual women, and fingerprints are formed 16 weeks after conception within the womb which could point to homosexuality being determined by genetic factors. In identical twins, researchers have also found that if one self-identifies as a gay man or lesbian the chance of the other being gay is greatly increased at 50%. Scientific inquiry into the reasons for homosexuality is still an emerging field of study, and more current research is constantly changing the way science views homosexuality.
It is worth noting though that many medical and scientific organisations do believe it is impossible to change a person's sexual orientation and displayed in a statement by American Academy of Pediatrics, American Counseling Association, American Association of School Administrators, American Federation of Teachers, American Psychological Association, American School Health Association, Interfaith Alliance Foundation, National Association of School Psychologists, National Association of Social Workers, and National Education Association, in 1999 reading:
- The most important fact about 'reparative therapy,' also sometimes known as 'conversion' therapy, is that it is based on an understanding of homosexuality that has been rejected by all the major health and mental health professions. The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Counseling Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychological Association, the National Association of School Psychologists, and the National Association of Social Workers, together representing more than 477,000 health and mental health professionals, have all taken the position that homosexuality is not a mental disorder and thus there is no need for a 'cure.' ...health and mental health professional organizations do not support efforts to change young people's sexual orientation through 'reparative therapy' and have raised serious concerns about its potential to do harm.
See homosexuality, genetics and sexual orientation and causes of sexual orientation for more information.
Lesbianism
Lesbians are less at risk of exposure to sexually transmitted diseases than any other group including heterosexuals. In certain types of cancer though this is not true, most likely because of barriers to care (social and psychological), they are less likely to receive regular screening examinations, and therefore more likely to present with advanced cases of cervical cancer or breast cancer. The general tendency among lesbians never to have been pregnant also increases the risk for both diseases. Although in recent years many lesbian couples are choosing to have in vitro fertilization and becoming pregnant to raise families. Some couples even have one partner donate the egg, then a medical doctor fertilizes the egg and places it within the other partner. (See Surrogacy) Many lesbians now prefer this method because they feel it to be more intimate when one partner gives birth to the other's biological child.
"Gay disease"
Various attempts have been made to define gay-only or gay-specific diseases, particularly during the 1970s. "Gay bowel syndrome" was a term first used in 1976, prior to the discovery of AIDS, to describe a series of parasitic disorders caused by oral/anal sexual contact. The term was abandoned by the medical community in the 1980s. The medical problems attributed to "gay bowel syndrome" were
- not specific to people of a specific sexual orientation
- not confined to the bowel
- not the medical definition of a syndrome
Similarly, a 2003 cluster of cases of MRSA-related skin infection found in gay men, schools, and prisons was initially labeled in press reports as a gay disease. In fact, there is no correlation between sexual orientation and MRSA infection or colonization.
The term "gay disease" in reference to AIDS is mostly used by religious objectors to same-sex relationships, who feel that lesbians and gay men are violating their religious doctrines and deserve punishment or divine retribution.
Referring to AIDS as a "gay disease" is also misleading. On a global scale, as of 2005 heterosexuals are more likely to acquire HIV, illustrating that a disease can strike anyone, regardless of sexual orientation.
See also
External Links
- American Psychiatric Association Statement
- American Psychological Association Statement
- American Acadmey Of Pediatrics Statement
- Fact Sheet Of Various Organisations
- Links To Various Scientific Studies
- Homosexuality: A Psychiatrist's Response to LDS Social Services
Resources For Lesbian & Gay Families
Medical & Scientific Organisations' Statements On Homosexuality
- American Psychiatric Association Statement
- American Psychological Association Statement
- American Acadmey Of Pediatrics Statement
- Fact Sheet Of Various Organisations
- Links To Various Scientific Studies
Categories: Sexual orientation and science